The USGA spoke to the media during their annual U.S. Open press conference on Wednesday covering a range of topics. The biggest of which dealt with the new high-definition video rules that will be implemented this week as well as eliminating the walking referee. With all eyes on the USGA after their egregious rules gaffes, most notably Dustin Johnson’s debacle at Oakmont in 2016, they are desperate to come up with the appropriate ruling solutions.
Golfweek’s Geoff Shackelford breaks it down for us while cautioning that this is still very much a work in progress:
The U.S. Golf Association announced a comprehensive effort to address high-definition U.S. Open rules incidents as part of a concerted effort to prevent future controversies. While most situations involving player intent to move a ball were already answered by a new local rule giving the player more discretion, the unveiling did not entirely settle questions about how future situations will play out. Here’s what was introduced Wednesday at Erin Hills:
A chief referee. Thomas Pagel, the USGA’s senior director of rules, becomes the USGA’s Chief Referee, empowered to make final decisions on rules questions. “We think of using another analogy from other sports, Thomas is our white hat referee,” John Bodenhamer, the USGA’s senior managing director of championships and governance, said. “Among all the black hats, he’s the white hat and empowered to make instantaneous decisions.”
A more mobile rules committee. “They’ll be in close communication with one another at all times,” Bodenhamer said. “And they’ll be able to make timely decisions, expedited decisions.”
On-course video review options. There will be four on-course video review locations for the committee, augmented by tablets, for reviewing video. However, the USGA did not commit to whether the tablets would be used for on-course reviews with players.
The end of walking referees. A “stationary referee model” ends the practice in place since 1991 where a rules official accompanied each group. Instead, there will be monitors assigned to each hole.
The USGA fails to fully clarify issue of high-definition rules incidents at #USOpen, writes @GeoffShac: https://t.co/SM8splSiW5 pic.twitter.com/CqeKpbDRCn
— Golfweek (@golfweek) June 14, 2017
The concepts seem like a logical reaction to the often-confusing situations related to golf video replay situations. But in practice, the USGA has no way of knowing if they’ve created a remedy or merely new headaches. Nor did the USGA present comforting visuals or reassuring evidence showing how Johnson’s situation would have been impacted.
“It’s a different situation because there’s no longer a penalty involved,” Bodenhamer said. “The determination needs to be whether it was accidental or something else other than the player caused that ball to move. If it’s accidental, no penalty, just put it back.”
While that may be enough to address the issue, the USGA could not rule out possibly looking at video reviews on tablets in the bright sunshine. Bodenhamer said every situation is different.
“I think our intention is for our committee to have the ability to review on course,” he said. “Not necessarily the player. I wouldn’t rule that out, but not necessarily. That’s not our intention. But our committee will have eyeballs on it.”
So while the tablets will show the committee video, it’s the chief referee who doesn’t really need their input according to Wednesday’s rollout.
“His decision would be final,’ Bodenhamer said. “And that is something we’ve empowered him with when the situation requires it. But we think in most instances there will be a consultation with the committee, as we always usually do.”
— — —
Keep yourself up-to-date with the latest goings-on in the world of golf by following the SwingxSwing Clubhouse on social media. We share stories, stats and breaking news on Twitter, keep the fun going off the course on Instagram and share any and all golf-related topics on Facebook.
Never be the odd golfer out when your friends are talking about the latest or funniest happenings in golf. Sign up for the SxS newsletter today!